Do you believe Liverpool has pulled off a masterstroke? Think they invested wisely-funds, passionate supporters, and cutting-edge infrastructure-to establish themselves as the premier football club worldwide?
Share your insights with us at [email protected]
Strategic Positioning: How Liverpool Set Themselves Up to Challenge the Best
Let me start by admitting that I’ve harbored some skepticism about FSG’s stewardship. My initial impression was that they stepped in after the tumultuous Hicks and Gillett era, doing an excellent job of stabilizing the club and steering it away from financial and organizational chaos.
They demonstrated a shrewd understanding of club management, appointing Jurgen Klopp-a manager who has delivered extraordinary success-and investing in sustainable growth for the club’s facilities, stadium, and overall infrastructure. This brief overview barely scratches the surface of a complex and multifaceted operation.
Admittedly, I should have appreciated these achievements more fully. As a passionate supporter, I often overlooked these foundational successes and instead fixated on perceived underinvestment in the squad.
The core of my frustration was that, during a 12-18 month period when Liverpool was arguably the best team on the planet (from May 2019 to January 2021, including Champions League victory in 2019, Club World Cup in 2020, and Premier League triumph in 2020), we squandered that momentum through unnecessary austerity measures.
By January 2021, key defenders like Van Dijk and Gomez had been sidelined for the season, with Joel Matip also injured. The club had previously sold Lovren, leaving us with no experienced center-backs. The transfer window that followed was chaotic, featuring the signings of Ben Davies and Ozan Kabak-both underwhelming and ultimately replaced by emerging talents Rhys Williams and Nat Phillips, who, despite their limitations, proved their worth.
Despite these efforts, the season faltered, and we narrowly qualified for the Champions League. Until recently, we struggled to reach the heights of our previous successes, revealing the fragility of our squad depth and planning.
Lessons from the Premier League’s Powerhouses
Growing up, I observed Manchester United’s approach: leverage success to acquire top-tier talent, creating a virtuous cycle of triumph and recruitment that cements their dominance. This strategy transformed United into a footballing titan, a club that consistently wins and sets standards.
In contrast, Liverpool’s post-2019 success seemed to be followed by a retreat-signing journeymen and unremarkable European prospects when reinforcements were needed most. It felt like a myopic view, akin to the shortsightedness of venture capitalists who focus solely on immediate gains.
The writing was on the wall. Liverpool’s achievements, driven by astute transfers and Klopp’s legendary coaching, appeared to signal a pause-waiting for a wealthy Middle Eastern investor to take an interest in football management, rather than a sustained, strategic build.
Subsequent transfer windows seemed to confirm this suspicion. It appeared that FSG was limiting transfer spending to merely secure Champions League qualification, often falling short of the spending levels of Manchester City or Arsenal. This approach made it increasingly difficult to maintain competitiveness.
Additionally, I harbored concerns that the club might be extracting funds through less transparent means. While FSG claimed they did not distribute dividends like the Glazers, I wondered if they were paying themselves consultancy fees-an inefficient form of remuneration that could be hidden within the club’s accounts, especially given the high salaries paid to staff.
Financial Transparency and Strategic Investment
However, reading “How to Win the Premier League,” a detailed account of Liverpool’s financial and strategic evolution, clarified that the club’s budget wasn’t arbitrarily constrained by American investors. Instead, it was a carefully calculated, scientific process-akin to a complex equation-aimed at ensuring long-term sustainability.
These financial experts, with PhDs in physics, understood the importance of managing resources meticulously. The club’s approach was not about reckless spending but about working within their means. The goal was clear: keep the club financially healthy while investing wisely.
Yet, a lingering question remained: if Liverpool was operating within its capacity, why did our expenditure stagnate even as revenues soared?
Between 2017 and 2019, Liverpool’s turnover increased by 50%, from just over €400 million to approximately €600 million. Despite this growth, our spending remained relatively modest-comparable to mid-table Premier League clubs-raising doubts about whether we were truly reinvesting our increased income.
Jurgen Klopp consistently emphasized the importance of retaining our best players, often hinting that the key to sustained success was holding onto our star talents rather than selling them. When Liverpool achieved European and domestic glory, our top players-Salah, Firmino, Mane, Wijnaldum, Henderson, Fabinho, Trent, Robertson, VVD, and Alisson-deserved significant pay rises, which inevitably increased our wage bill.
While some players left on free transfers or for financial incentives, the most substantial expenses went to maintaining our star squad-particularly those owned by the club or operated under oligarchic ownership models.
This realization didn’t diminish my optimism entirely; it simply reinforced that Liverpool’s success was rooted in excellent coaching and recruitment. The recent squad overhaul-replacing aging midfielders like Henderson, Thiago, Fabinho, Milner, and Oxlade-Chamberlain with younger, more dynamic players-demonstrated our capacity to adapt and climb back to the summit.
However, the pattern was clear: wages would inevitably rise, and transfer budgets would tighten. The club’s ambitious plan to break the British transfer record for a world-class talent was a surprise, diverging from the previous strategy of measured, sustainable growth.
Infrastructure and Revenue Growth: Building for the Future
Historically, Liverpool invested revenues into infrastructure projects-most notably, stadium expansion and modernization. These investments, while initially impacting short-term finances, have paid dividends. The £50 million ground upgrade has been completed, and Anfield now seats over 61,000 fans, many of whom are high-paying season ticket holders and corporate clients.
Projected revenue for 2024/2025 is expected to surpass £115 million-almost £40 million more than in 2019. Over the past eight years, commercial income has surged by £36 million annually, reaching £308 million in 2024. Notably, commercial revenue now accounts for over half of total income, reflecting the club’s growing global brand.
Our recent appearances in three Champions League finals within five years have not only generated substantial earnings but also enhanced Liverpool’s reputation worldwide. While Manchester United’s global dominance has waned, Liverpool has risen to fill that void, attracting new fans and increasing revenues-an indication of the club’s rising stature in the modern football landscape.
Unlike in the past, Liverpool now possesses the financial muscle to assemble a world-class squad without risking catastrophic debt. This shift positions us to compete at the highest levels, both domestically and in Europe.
Manchester City has already spent over £200 million in the latest transfer window, yet their squad may not be significantly superior to Liverpool’s. With 115 points currently separating City from the top, and Pep Guardiola approaching the end of his tenure, the landscape is ripe for Liverpool to challenge for supremacy.
Manchester United, meanwhile, faces a long road to recovery, hampered by financial constraints and managerial instability. Arsenal, with a talented squad at a prime age and a sensible budget, presents a credible threat to Liverpool’s ambitions.
FSG and Liverpool’s leadership seem to have recognized a rare opportunity: with the right investments, we can build a squad capable of winning both European and domestic titles consistently. This would involve recruiting from a position of strength, leveraging our financial power and rich history to attract the best talents globally.
The Premier League remains the world’s premier football competition, and Liverpool’s goal is to become its most successful and influential club. If we succeed in this endeavor, we could rival giants like Real Madrid and Barcelona, ultimately establishing a new era of dominance rooted in strategic excellence and financial strength.
– Ed Ern
Additional Insights from F365
- Liverpool: Arne Slot ‘approves’ another signing as defender ‘arrives in UK to finalize’ summer transfer
- Barcelona ‘offers’ former Manchester City star to Liverpool for Slot’s preferred starter, who’s ‘pushing to leave’
- Top 10 biggest transfer window spends ever as Liverpool prepares to splurge
Supporters’ Conduct and Expectations
Are Liverpool fans finally earning praise for their consistency? Howard Jones from Tuesday’s mailbox suggests that supporters deserve recognition for their unwavering support, even when it involves defending a player’s reputation. However, it’s worth noting that supporting your team means backing your players-whether they’re staying or leaving. That’s the essence of being a true supporter.
Remember: You’ll Never Walk Alone. Unless you switch allegiances. Racism is unacceptable, but simply booing a departing player is part of the game’s tradition. Supporters are expected to stand by their team, and that includes showing disappointment when appropriate.
– Kim Johannesen
Reflections on Liverpool’s Tragedies and Broader Football Issues
My thoughts are with those affected by recent tragedies-an act of violence that marred what should have been a joyful occasion. Liverpool, as a city and club, has endured immense pain-from the Hillsborough disaster to the press and authorities’ mishandling of the aftermath. Our resilience remains unbroken.
On a different note, questions arise about Manchester United’s future: Will Erik ten Hag’s departure to Leverkusen trigger a mass exodus? Can he replicate his success elsewhere, or will he struggle to find the same level of achievement? The transfer market remains unpredictable, with players like Cunha linked to United-yet many wonder if they’re better off elsewhere, given the club’s current instability.
For United fans contemplating a squad overhaul, the challenge lies in balancing wages and quality. Champions League qualification remains crucial, not just for revenue but for attracting top talent. A long-term rebuild may be necessary, with patience and strategic planning guiding the way. The prospect of changing coaches mid-season adds complexity, but the ultimate goal remains clear: restoring United’s former glory.
Meanwhile, Liverpool, Arsenal, Manchester City, and Chelsea continue their pursuit of excellence. Liverpool’s ambition is to truly compete at the highest level, aiming to establish a sustained period of dominance-something that could redefine the club’s legacy in the modern era.
Ranking the Premier League’s Best Seasons
This is a subjective ranking of all Premier League seasons, from most successful to least, designed to settle debates once and for all (until next season).
- Crystal Palace – Their first major trophy, a historic achievement.
- Liverpool – League champions, a feat that truly matters.
- Newcastle – Surprising many with a League Cup win and Champions League qualification, given their history and resources.
- Tottenham – Trophies matter, and their Europa League run was significant.
- Nottingham Forest – Exceeded expectations with a thrilling campaign and a real shot at European silverware next year.
- Aston Villa – Secured Champions League qualification, with promising signs under Unai Emery.
- Everton – Managed to leave Goodison Park with a positive campaign, avoiding relegation chaos.
- Chelsea – Achieved their targets, maintaining stability amid a transitional period.
- Brighton – Enjoyed a pleasant season with notable victories and a relaxed vibe.
- Arsenal – A personal bias, but their consistent performance and entertaining style made it a memorable season.
- Bournemouth – Showed flashes of brilliance, with a solid FA Cup run.
- Fulham – Good cup runs and respectable league position, though less impressive compared to others.
- Brentford – Similar to Fulham, but with less success in cups and potential squad changes looming.
- Wolves – Avoided relegation comfortably and showed signs of upward trajectory.
- Manchester City – Qualified for the Champions League but underwhelmed at times, with inconsistent performances.
- West Ham – Showed some promise but overall regressed, facing ongoing challenges.
- Leicester – Celebrated Vardy’s farewell, but overall a disappointing campaign.
- Manchester United – A difficult season, with struggles reflecting their broader decline.
- Southampton – Near the bottom, but avoided the worst record in Premier League history.
- Ipswich – A historically poor season, with little to celebrate.
– Dave, South Wales
Football’s Ongoing Debates and Fan Perspectives
Congratulations to Bladey Mick for delivering one of the most inconsistent yet insightful football posts ever. It’s a stark reminder that football fans are rarely fully satisfied.
Mick criticizes VAR’s inconsistent application-highlighting that in one match, VAR correctly intervened, while in another, it failed due to referee error. The key takeaway? VAR’s utility depends on the officials’ decisions; it’s not infallible but can be a valuable tool when used correctly.
Supporters should aim for fairness and consistency, recognizing that VAR’s role is to assist referees, not replace them. When used properly, it can correct mistakes; when misapplied, it undermines confidence in the game.
– Mike, LFC, Dubai
